October 24 - 30, 2021: Issue 515


Life’s A Beach: Finding Trends In Marine Debris Across Australia

OceanWatch mangroves and bay clean - Careel Bay 2012 - A J Guesdon photo

by University of New South Wales

Plastic is 84 per cent of all rubbish found across Australian beaches, a UNSW-led study based on one of the largest marine debris databases in the Southern Hemisphere has found.

More than 2000 organisations and 150,000 citizen scientists have participated in the Australian Marine Debris Initiative [AMDI] by sorting and tallying up marine debris they have collected since it was set up by the not-for-profit Tangaroa Blue Foundation in 2004.

Now a study led by UNSW Science has filtered and analysed 10 years of the AMDI Database and created a national map of patterns in marine debris.

The study found that almost half of all debris could be related to land-based sources [litter and dumping on land] and seven per cent to dumping at sea.

But 42 per cent of debris could not be related definitively to a source due to the debris breaking down into smaller fragments, which the researchers say highlights the legacy of plastic left in our environment, continually fragmenting into smaller pieces until it is microplastics.

The findings have been published in Science of The Total Environment.

"The AMDI Database contains entries of beach clean-ups across Australia, but the added value of this database is that volunteers take the time to categorise what they find, sorting and counting the amounts of plastic, glass, rubber, metal, paper and other items," study lead author and PhD candidate, Jordan Gacutan from UNSW Science's Centre for Marine Science and Innovation in the School of Biological, Earth and Environmental Sciences says.

"We can combine this rich data over space and time to get patterns of the marine debris and plastic problem across Australia.

"This study shows, with unprecedented resolution, the variation in debris items both regionally and across Australia."

A map of the accumulated count [per day] of all debris averaged per clean-up site across the Australian coast. Coasts with insufficient sites were not considered in the analysis. Graphic: Jordan Gacutan

Study co-author and Dean of UNSW Science, Professor Emma Johnston, says very few environmental stresses are able to be measured on a national scale.

"So the 150,000 citizen scientists who have contributed to this database are doing an amazing favour for Australia," Prof. Johnston says.

"Their passion for the environment gives us one of the few continental scale insights into the global marine problem."

For the AMDI Database, the Tangaroa Blue Foundation developed a method of categorising and counting all the rubbish collected by a range of citizen scientists and partner organisations, from families to government campaigns.

"We designed the methodology, host it and manage the database, but the data is owned by 150,000 people that have contributed to that database," study co-author and Tangaroa Blue Foundation founder and chief executive officer Heidi Tait says.

"This is the impact of working together and the results really highlight that one intervention isn't going to solve the plastics in our oceans issue, and one sector or one stakeholder group is not going to be able to solve it on their own either.

"We need to collaborate and this network is a perfect example of partners who have achieved something quite monumental."

The AMDI Database now has almost 20 million entries, but the UNSW study focused on the 10-year period from when the database registered beach clean-ups at a national level.

Drawing patterns from items on the beach

Ms Tait says the AMDI Database showed there was a very different marine debris signature at a regional scale.

"The data shows that what we find in Cape York is completely different to what we find in Port Phillip Bay in Melbourne," she says.

The UNSW study looked at the national picture, but also grouped its findings according to the six 'bioregions' the Australian government uses to manage our oceans and coasts.

These are: North (Northern Territory to Cape York), North-west (WA); South-west (lower WA and SA); South-east (including Victoria and Tasmania) and Temperate east (mainly NSW) and Coral Sea/Great Barrier Reef Marine Park.

Mr Gacutan says that by looking at what items were found on beaches, we can better understand the problem items and where they came from.

"Some bioregions have a high amount of fishing debris, such as fishing floats and nets, while others have a bigger problem with littering, and you can identify these patterns through what items you find on these coastal clean-ups," he says.

The South-east and South-west regions have higher amounts of fishing items, but on the other hand, the Temperate East had three times the proportion of cigarette butts, compared to the national average, which shows a problem with local litter, the study suggested.

The study found about 40 per cent of all marine debris across Australia was from littering, particularly near capital cities where a lot of plastic ends up on the beach from stormwater drains.

"On the other hand, although Cape York in Queensland had a huge amount of debris, most of it came from external sources, for example floats and plastic bottles that might have been dumped both at sea or floated from other countries."

"We know that Cape York is very, very remote so the amount of plastic we're finding on beaches isn't contributed by the people living there," Mr Gacutan says.

Ms Tait says that better evidence needs to be used to inform how we manage the growing marine debris problem.

"We need to be really targeted and strategic in what changes are put in place to mitigate marine debris, and we need to measure and monitor to make sure we are actually solving the problem, that's where the data is going to be so critical moving forward," she says.

Improving citizen science for management

Dr Graeme Clark, senior author of the study and Senior Research Associate at UNSW, says the study focused on filtering the data to make sure that it was as accurate and reliable as possible before it was used.

"One of the main concerns that people have with citizen science data is the quality, accuracy and reliability of the data that we're getting from these clean-ups," he says.

"You do get a huge variability in the quality, for example some people might start cleaning the grassed area at a beach, or the car park; children collect differently from adults; and this really limits comparisons between sites.

"We tried to maximise the quality of the data and control the sites that we looked at by really conservative filtering.

"We only looked at sites that were sandy, ocean facing, and weren't modified by structures like seawalls and breakwaters."

Dr Clark says that the methods presented by the UNSW team could impact how citizen science databases are used and improve how marine debris data is collected globally.

"Improving the quality and rigour of citizen science data makes it easier to use in management and decision making," he says.

"Citizen science datasets are powerful tools for marine debris monitoring and can help shape management plans to better tackle the problem of marine debris and plastic pollution at a localised level.

Ms Tait says the most unique aspect of the AMDI Database is that it's based on a scalable model which identifies the source of the debris.

"If you look at what's currently happening internationally with discussions around global treaties on plastic, nationally with the National Plastics Plan, and state government plans to address single-use plastics: how are we going to measure those to make sure that those policies are having impact?," she says.

"For example, if a Global Treaty on Plastics is formalised through the United Nations, we should see the 95 per cent of international marine debris we find in Cape York decrease in the future if this treaty is successful.

"This is a way to measure the impact of mitigation strategies that are put in place to see whether they're actually making a positive impact and reducing marine debris and litter at the source."

Jordan Gacutan, Emma L. Johnston, Heidi Tait, Wally Smith, Graeme F. Clark. Continental patterns in marine debris revealed by a decade of citizen science. Science of The Total Environment, 2022; 807: 150742 DOI: 10.1016/j.scitotenv.2021.150742

  • Up to 40,000 pieces of plastic are estimated to float in every square kilometre of ocean. 800 species worldwide including 77 Australian species are impacted by marine debris. Over 75% of what is removed from our beaches is made of plastic.
  • With more than 8 million tons of plastic entering the ocean every year marine debris has become one of the major environmental issues worldwide. Since the world’s population, plastic production and consumption are growing exponentially there is no end in sight regarding the ever increasing amount of waste ending up in the environment and making its way into the ocean – about 75% of it being plastics.
  • The piles of rubbish we find on beaches is only the tip of the ice/plastic-berg. It is estimated that by 2050 by weight we will have more plastic than fish in the ocean.
  • Since the invention of plastic in the 1950s this durable and never decomposing material has not only taken over our lives, but is also taking over our environment.
  • Some effects such as the risk of entanglement and ingestion for wildlife, the decrease of economic value from polluted beaches in touristic areas or the hazard for human health and safety are well documented. But plastic breaks up into ever smaller pieces over time. We have just begun to understand the impacts of those microplastics and the toxins attached to them on entire ecosystems and humans.
  • Whilst a lot of research is needed, we can assume that due to the sheer scale of the problem serious long term consequences could affect our way of life as it is already affecting the health of our ocean

Issue 511: Data From 29,798 Clean-Ups Around The World Uncovers Some Of The Worst Litter Hotspots + Australia Signs Pacific Regional Declaration On The Prevention Of Marine Litter and Plastic Pollution and Its Impacts

OceanWatch mangroves and bay clean - Careel Bay 2012; ute in background shows bags full of plastics, cigarette butts and more collected - A J Guesdon photo
One of the Careel Bay locals seen at same OceanWatch Clean - a Mangrove or Striated Heron Butorides striata - same shorebird in Careel Creek to show detail:

The Green Team and Surfrider Norther Beaches members doing a beach clean at Living a Plastic Free Life Festival, 2018 - A J Guesdon photos