North Narrabeen in 1911 - Panoramas taken for West's Lakeside Estate
While doing some research in the digitised records provided online by the National Archives of Australia these three panoramas popped up, and are listed, via their original file names as:
1: Panoramic Photograph of Narrabeen and Collaroi Beach from West's Lakeside Estate.:
2: Panoramic Photograph of View of Narrabeen Lakes from West's Lakeside Estate:
3: Panoramic Photograph of View of Narrabeen Lakes from West's Lakeside Estate:
These photos were taken and sections and put together by the 'Exchange Studios of 49 Pitt Street'. The same firm also took panoramas of Manly during this era. The first panoramic photographs were created in the 1840s by assembling multiple images into single scenes. By 1898, specialised panoramic cameras such as the Al-Vista were being mass produced in America.
The renowned American panoramic photographer Mervin Vaniman visited Australia in 1903–04, further popularising the artform. Australian photographers including Robert Henry Ward and William Charles Farran, and Augustus George Sands recognised potential commercial opportunities. They applied for artistic copyright then exhibited and sold souvenir booklets and large-format prints of their work.
They worked successfully for years before dissolving their partnership:
WARD & FARRAN (Robert Henry Ward & William Charles Farran, trading.as), Exchange Studios, 49 Pitt-st., Sydney—Reported partnership dissolved as from September 24. Wm. Chas. Farran & Peter Volkert Payeris continue under the name of .“The Exchange Studios. ” (October 24 1921). BUSINESS CHANGES, ETC, Dun's gazette for New South Wales Retrieved June 8, 2025, from http://nla.gov.au/nla.obj-779841052
They show not much had changed between the above and when this photo was taken form around the same aspect:

West's Lakeside Estate refers to the land holdings of the West family here.
Obed West was born December 4 1807 in Pitt Street, Sydney, in a house on the eastern bank of the Tank Stream between what is now Martin Place and King Street. He was the son of convict parents, Thomas West (1773-1858) and Mary Rugg (circa 1769-1865).
In 1810 West's father obtained Barcom Glen, a 75-acre (30 ha) property above Rushcutter's Bay, to construct and operate a water mill for milling flour and West lived there from that date until his death in 1891. In 1836, his father conveyed the property to him on condition that he not sell, alienate or dispose of any of it, except by leases not exceeding 19 years. The land, at the edge of the inner Sydney suburb of Paddington, therefore remained largely undeveloped at least until 1910. It was said that the property remained, at West's death, "an oasis of verdant green and spreading forest trees in a wilderness of terraced houses". The family home at Barcom Glen was demolished in 1912.
In 1831 he married Jane Margaret Lindsey (1811-1875) at St James’ Church, Sydney, with whom he had 14 children! Those children are listed by descendants as:
Sarah J Blackwood; Mary Ann Wilcox; Rebecca Elizabeth West; Thomas John West; Obediah West; Jane Margaret Dobson - Haynes; Naomi Cooper; Louisa Jane Alcorn; Caroline Amelia Iredale; Edward Augustus Sydney West; Emily Matilda McLauchlan; Margaret Lucy Marriott; Clara Mary Elizabeth West and Arthur Owen West.
He was a businessman and milled flour with his father's watermill - the first of its type for grinding flour in Sydney. He also bred cattle in the Camden district, and carried on a dairy business and grew fruit at Barcom Glen.
Obed West (1807-1891) bought land in North Narrabeen in 1881 and 1883, during the first land sales of the acres from Collaroy to Narrabeen Lagoon. His son, Thomas John West, would become President of what was called the Narrabeen Progress Association, a position he held until he passed away in 1906. T J West was also an Alderman (current day term is 'Councillor') on the City and Paddington Councils of his era.
Obed also became well-known for sharing his insights into early Sydney in local newspapers as he became older, and because people wanted to know more about what happened here before they were born.
TO THE EDITOR. OF THE HERALD.
Sir,-I read with a great deal of satisfaction the letter in your columns from Mr. James Norton, in which he directs attention to the wholesale and increasing destruction of our native plants and flowers through the medium of these shows. I deplore with him the rapid extirpation of our beautiful wild flowers, ferns, and indigenous plants in the districts adjacent to Sydney, and think that the show craze is assuming such proportions that it should be restrained. The floral wealth of our bush is disappearing rapidly enough in other ways without the extravagant appropriation that is made from it every year for these displays. We have not merely to consider the flowers and plants taken away, but it is the quantity, ruthlessly destroyed by the collectors, who care not what damage they do provided they can make up their dray loads.
I have had experience of this on my property at Lake Narrabeen, which I purposely purchased to preserve the beautiful cabbage-trees, ferns, and lilly-pilly trees upon it; and much as I admire the object for which the exhibitions are held, I cannot refrain from expressing the opinion that they are doing a deal of harm in the direction pointed out by Mr. Norton. The interval between the shows is far too short, and the contributions levied upon our native plants far too exacting. In a short time the beauty of the bush and gullies around Sydney and Pittwater, so much appreciated by strangers for their profuse adornment of native flowers and ferns, will be gone, and I think it behoves those profess a love for our indigenous plants to see that the present wanton destruction is stayed. The mischief is rapidly growing; the example set by Manly Beach is being followed by others, and this month we are having the bush and the gullies ransacked in every direction to supply the shows at North Shore and Kogarah, in addition to the one at Manly. I hope Mr. Norton's protest will have the effect of directing the attention of the promoters of these exhibitions to the injury they are, I believe unwittingly, doing to the beauty spots around their own and other localities near Sydney.
OBED WEST.
Barcom Glen. TO THE EDITOR OF THE HERALD. (1885, September 28). The Sydney Morning Herald (NSW : 1842 - 1954), p. 5. Retrieved from http://nla.gov.au/nla.news-article28364152
Mount Ramsay Estate subdivision, near Narrabeen, L88— Mr Obed West, sen, ; lot 8, section G, ... SALES OF PROPERTY. (1883, December 22). The Sydney Daily Telegraph (NSW : 1879 -1883), p. 7. Retrieved from http://nla.gov.au/nla.news-article239272826


THE LAKE DISTRICTS OF PITT-WATER AND NARRABEEN.
A PROGRESSIVE MOVEMENT.
There are many parts of Sydney and its suburbs better known to most people than the charming district comprising Narrabeen, Pittwater, Newport. etc.. which stretches away to the north-west of Manly, skirting the ocean on one side, and extending on the other to the picturesque reaches of the Hawkesbury. Yet there is no more delightful and bracing spot among the many pleasure resorts of the metropolis. At a first glance it seems difficult to understand why there should be this ignorance, especially in view of the nearness of the district to Sydney. In all probability it is owing lo the fact that the harbor divides the district from Sydney proper, and that thousands who visit Manly each year regard that pleasant watering-place as being in that direction the ''Land's End" of the colony. But the residents are now bestirring themselves to impress the claims of their district for larger share of consideration In the expenditure of Government money on local improvements, and also for the construction of a tramway to open up the district from Manly, If not all the way from Sydney, via the Spit. The difficulty of taking the line the on the distance is the cost of a bridge across Middle Harbor, but it is believed that a line could be constructed from Manly which would pay well within a very short time of completion, as far as Narrabeen, if not even to Pittwater.
On Saturday evening last the various Progress Committees of the district foregathered at a banquet held in the Narrabeen Hotel for the purpose of ventilating their views on the subject, and by way of Initiating a combined movement on the part of these districts to advance their common interests. There were over 40 gentlemen present, including Mr. T. J. West (Mayor of Paddington), who occupied the chair, the Rev. A. G. Stoddart, Mr. Passau (Mayor of Manly), Mr. D. C. M'Lachlan, Mr. J. Taylor, Mr. John Woods (of Manly), Mr. Iredale, and the chairmen of the Narrabeen, Newport, and Pittwater Progress Committees. An excellent spread was provided, and a lengthy list of toasts having been honored, the larger property-owners present, as well as several influential visitors, pledged themselves to do all in their power to secure improved means of communication with the district, and a working committee was formed to take the matter in hand. THE LAKE DISTRICTS OF PITTWATER AND NARRABEEN. (1898, March 30). The Daily Telegraph (Sydney, NSW : 1883 - 1930), p. 4. Retrieved from http://nla.gov.au/nla.news-article238375681
FOR CITY GIRLS holiday home
MEMBERS of the City Girls Amateur Sports Association have completed negotiations for a week-end holiday house at Narrabeen. "Palm Cottage" is an ideal place for a holiday, with the ocean in front and the big lake at the back. The creeks, too, offer pleasure to those whose fancy turns to quiet, inland waters. Mr. T. West, who built "Palm Cottage," went to Narrabeen in 1884, and from almost the whole coastline chose the site because it provided such an unusual vista of the sea. The house will accommodate 12 girls for each week-end, and it will probably be used for holidays also.
PALM COTTAGE The house at Narrabeen which has been secured by the City Girls' Amateur Sports Association for a week-end resort. FOR CITY GIRLS (1926, March 1). The Sun (Sydney, NSW : 1910 - 1954), p. 13 (FINAL EXTRA). Retrieved fromhttp://nla.gov.au/nla.news-article224055821
City Girls
New Holiday House At Narrabeen
PALM Cottage, one of the oldest houses In Narrabeen, Is to be the scene of many happy weekend parties for the City Girls' Amateur Sports Association. The cottage is large, and rambling, surrounded by wide verandahs, and stands on a hill, overlooking the ocean beach on one side and the Narrabeen Lakes on the other. It is an ideal place for large parties of club girls, the ample balcony space making It possible to accommodate unlimited numbers of camp stretchers for sleeping out, while a specially glassed-in portion will lend itself to the use of long, trestle dining-tables, to seat at least 20 girls.
The lawns surrounding the house are excellently suited for circles courts and basket-ball. Already a number of clubs affiliated to the C.G.A.S.A. have booked up week-ends well into the winter, for the colder weather will make no difference, as the charm of boating on the lakes and tramping into the woods surrounding them will afford sufficient interest as a substitute for the joys of surfing. Each girl, with a minimum number of eight, will be charged five shillings for a party. At present there is only accommodation for twelve, but, as the popularity of Palm Cottage grows, the association will be prepared to arrange for further accommodation. City Girls (1926, March 11). The Daily Telegraph (Sydney, NSW : 1883 - 1930), p. 4 (The Daily Telegraph Woman's Supplement). Retrieved from http://nla.gov.au/nla.news-article245839929
It is likely the road on the southern side of the lagoon was first built due to the West family selling off their Narrabeen land, although its extension and climb up to Collaroy Plateau, along with the land at that end of the lagoon for the Veterans Village, was resumed in part, through the work of the then Warringah Shire Council, from the Wheeler family:
Plan of Subdivision.
An owner of property submitted a plan of subdivision of an estate at Narrabeen to the Warringah Shire Council for approval. He proposed to allow a road around the waters of the Lake that would provide a beautiful parade, if the council would make some concession in return. Plan of Subdivision. (1911, October 20). The Land (Sydney, NSW : 1911 - 1954), p. 9. Retrieved from http://nla.gov.au/nla.news-article102900950
This notification about bringing some of the Wheeler land (paddocks) under the Real Property Act shows how the West family Narrbeen holdings were then held by a few family members:
No. 16,973. APPLICANT James Wheeler, Narrabeen. LAND : County Cumberland, parish Manly Cove, shire Warringah, 1 acre 1 rood 31 1/2 perches, 3 roods 18 perches, 1 acre 3 roods 1 perch, 3 acres 11 perches, 1 acre 3 roods 3 perches, 34 perches, 1 rood 30 1/2 perches, 35 perches, 2 roods 2 1/2 perches, 1 rood 30 1/2 perches, 2 roods 2 3/4 perches, and 2 acres 3 roods If perches, in Jenkins, Frazer, Ramsay, Stuart, Wetherill, Clarke, Mactier, Goodwin, Devitt, Lagoon, Wellington, and Park streets, and on Narrabeen Lagoon,—lots 22 to 28. section 8; lots 9, 16, 17, 18, section 11: lots 10 to 14 and 17. 18, 19, scction 12; lots 13 to 26, section 16; lots 12 to 15 and 18 to 21, section 19: part lot 14a, section 20: lots 3, 4, 7, 11, 12, 13, section 21: lots 12, 13. section 22: lots 5, 7, 8, section 26: part lot 2: and lots 3 to 8, section 42, Mount Ramsay Estate: and part 410 acres (portion 1,217 of parish) granted to John Ramsay: adjoining properties of J. Wheeler, R. Pfoeffer, C. A. S. Hayden, E. A. Powell, C. M. E. West, H. S. Haynes, E J. West, Mrs. E. M. Loader, A. E. Ellis, C. A. de Kantzow, D. McLean, A. O. West, H. H. Gordon, W. Pollard, W. S. Beale, W. A. Lipscombe, W. L. McFarlane, estate J. Langley, J. F. C. Goodridge, A. E. Dowling, W. Nicholls, T. H. Page, and G. L. Pring. NOTICE UNDER REAL PROPERTY ACT. (1911, August 30). Government Gazette of the State of New South Wales (Sydney, NSW : 1901 - 2001), p. 4711. Retrieved from http://nla.gov.au/nla.news-article230685900


Narrabeen, Star photo, circa 1900-1910. Item a116483h courtesy State Library of NSW

Narrabeen lagoon, circa 1915, Item hall_34703h, courtesy State Library of NSW
.jpg?timestamp=1749338397954)
.jpg?timestamp=1749338652037)
.jpg?timestamp=1749338696434)
.jpg?timestamp=1749338730626)
.jpg?timestamp=1749338787920)
.jpg?timestamp=1749338819568)

.jpg?timestamp=1749338899367)
.jpg?timestamp=1749338935846)
.jpg?timestamp=1749338965544)
.jpg?timestamp=1749338992005)
.jpg?timestamp=1749339019924)

References
- Pittwater Roads II: Where the Streets Have your Name - Narrabeen
- Narrabeen Hotel: Some History About The Licensees
- Pictures From The Past: Views Of Early Narrabeen Bridges - 1860 to 1966
Title Primary Application - Edith Mary Loder, Edward Thomas West & Ada Blanche Ellis, Clarke Mactier Park & Wetherill Streets & a Government Road 66 feet wide and on Narrabeen Lagoon Shire Warringah Parish Manly Cove Volume 2210 Folios 132 to 137
Contents Date Range: 24-04-1911 to 15-12-1911 NRS-17513-4-87-Primary Application 17140 - in Volume 2210 Folios 132 to 137 - Septimus Charles Lindley (Vol-Fol 2210-135) and George Washington Walker (Vol-Fol 2210-136) with Charles Aldophus De Kantzow (Vol-Fol 2210-137) - has 12 acres, 2 roods and 23 1/2 perches together, making up the bulk of the 'West's Lake-side Estate', indicating the few lots then owned by the West family, subsumed into these sales, was used to promote the land sales through association with the family that had served and promoted that stretch of North Narrabeen since the commencement of the land sales.