November 1 - 30, 2026: Issue 660

 

Avalon Rockpool renewal: concerns over scale of concrete proposed, fence at southeast Perimeter, concrete walkway within the pool


Although the exhibition period for feedback on the proposed renewal of Avalon Beach rockpool has closed, residents have requested their concerns go on record here.

The first that came in was a proposed stainless steel fence at the SE end of the pool. More than one resident has pointed out this would, by its nature, prohibit walking the perimeter of the pool or diving into to the pool from that end, not to mention greatly altering the character of the pool, and its views south.

The plans show a proposal to 'remove the existing fence and install a new stainless steel fence on the inner ledge':

Comments to the news service have been ''this seems, quite frankly, absurd.''

Under the council's frequently asked questions on the project webpage is:

Why is Council proposing to install a fence on the inside edge of the southern wall at Avalon Beach Rockpool?

The response is:

'The southern wall of Avalon Beach Rockpool is regularly affected by wave overtopping, which can make the top of the wall slippery and difficult for Council staff to safely clean and maintain. When these conditions occur, algae and marine growth can accumulate, increasing the risk of slips and falls.

To improve safety, we are proposing a fence along the inside edge of the southern wall only to discourage access to the top of the wall during periods when maintenance cannot be safely undertaken. The fence is an additional safety measure that complements the proposed maintenance access improvements and helps reduce risks to pool users.'

Further concerns have been expressed by several more about the amount and scale of concrete proposed to be installed and particularly the proposed concrete walkway slab to be installed on the pool floor, with the natural floor to be retained elsewhere. Safety has been cited as the reason for these two concrete walkways within the pool itself, alongside the south and east walls, however, these could also become hazards for those using the pool when they butt against them and would become slippery and dangerous once the  seaweed in the pool has colonised it.

Sue Martin OAM, a long-term resident who has been part of the Avalon Beach rockpool community for decades, states:

''I have concerns about the proposal to place a 90 cm internal concrete pathway slab on the natural rock ledge along the base of two walls of Avalon Beach Rockpool.

NBC says that the purpose of the internal concrete pathway on the rock ledge is to improve maintenance and safe walking access for the pool cleaners, once a fortnight in winter and once a week in summer. The concrete pathway would have no other function. I wonder why the current cleaning process, which has operated for decades, needs to change so radically. Some people believe they will be able to walk in the water around the pool, similar to the situation at Bilgola. This is not the intention.

NBC commented that the concrete pathway would improve safety for people working in the dark. The staff do not work in the dark. There is a light overlooking the pool. The time for emptying and cleaning the pool is determined by the low tide, day or night.

Another justification for a new concrete pathway is that the bottom of the pool can be slippery when emptied. A concrete pathway would also be slippery. 

Avalon Rockpool, unlike Palm Beach or Bilgola cement pools, is a living aquarium. I wonder if the people who drew up the concept plan have swum in Avalon Rockpool and seen the rock ledge bottom with the living seaweed and marine life. Are the concept developers aware that the rock ledge area proposed for the concrete pathway is uneven with significant variations in depth? This would presumably provide a challenge for the laying of a 90cm wide level concrete slab path and require a significant depth of concrete at certain spots along the sides of the rock pool. 

As someone who has swum year-round for more than thirty years, I am aware that at times, the rock pool is full of seaweed. However, often subsequent high tides remove it. Two years ago, at Christmas there was a significant problem with rotting seaweed at Avalon in the pool and on the beach. This was, of course, the problem at every other beach. We accept that those are the issues associated with an ocean rock pool. I dispute that it has been of a frequency and extent that would warrant the significant invasion of a concrete pathway specifically for the use of the cleaners in our living aquarium.

I appreciate NBC’s sense of responsibility. However, I consider that the proposal for a concrete pathway is an overreaction to the issue of cleaning the pool. It would be an unacceptable and significant disfigurement of a beautiful heritage rock pool.

Please, if you have strong feelings send your comments to Northern Beaches Council.''

Further FAQ's explain:

Is Council proposing to concrete the floor of Avalon Beach Rockpool?

Response:

No. We are seeking to retain the appearance and character of the pool as much as possible.

A narrow concrete walkway is proposed along 2 walls of the pool to provide a safe walking surface, improve access in response to community requests, and enable Council staff to safely undertake cleaning and maintenance of the pool walls. The remainder of the pool floor will remain natural rock.

Is Council proposing to increase the height of Avalon Rockpool's walls and pool deck?

Response:

Our preferred approach is to retain the existing wall and deck levels through demolition and reconstruction, helping to maintain the existing character and appearance of the rockpool.

However, if precast panels are adopted as the preferred construction method, the pool deck and wall heights would increase by approximately 200mm. Precast panels are being considered as they can improve constructability and reduce the time required for construction when working in Avalon's challenging coastal environment. This option has not been confirmed and remains subject to detailed design.

How will safety and accessibility be improved?

Response:

The proposed works include upgrades to access points, stairs, ramps, handrails and other safety features to improve access and usability.

Will there be any impacts on parking?

Response:

The contractor will require a compound for storage of materials during the work. The final location of this will be subject to Council approval prior to construction commencement.

​Is Council proposing to install a ramp at Avalon Rockpool?

Response:

No, a ramp is not proposed for Avalon Rockpool.

To improve access and safety for pool users, we are proposing to enlarge the existing upper stair landing area and construct new stairs into the pool. This approach provides a safer entry and exit point for users while retaining the existing character and appearance of the rockpool as much as possible.

Will the works be noisy?

Construction works may generate temporary noise impacts, which will be managed in accordance with the Review of Environmental Factors (REF).

Unfortunately the Review of Environmental Factors document was not released for residents to scrutinise as part of the consultation for reasons undisclosed.

The Works are scheduled for next year and expected to commence in late Autumn for completion in Spring. No access to the pool or pool surrounds will be available during that time.

Council's project webpage states:

The renewal of Avalon Beach Rockpool will be carried out mid-2027.

The renewal of Bilgola Rockpool will be carried out mid-2028.

Sue Martin OAM at Avalon Beach Rockpool. Photo: A J Guesdon/PON



The bathing pool Avalon Beach  - photos by Rex Hazlewood, circa 1920-1925 Images Courtesy The Mitchell Library, State Library of NSW, No.: c046220002h and c046220014h